What is healthier than Essentuki, Narzan or Borjomi

"Essentuki 4" for gastritis

“Essentuki 4” is considered medicinal water, having a chloride-bicarbonate sodium composition. As for the mineralization of this drink, it is 8 – 10 g/l. Gastroenterologists recommend this useful liquid for gastritis with high acidity, which is accompanied by preserved, increased or decreased acidity. It will also be useful when diagnosing stomach and duodenal ulcers, colitis, liver disease, and diabetes.

Water is extracted from a 90-meter depth of the Essentuki field. Immediately on the spot, the liquid is poured into containers. This is necessary to preserve its features. Experts say that during transportation all healing properties are lost. That is why the manufacturer organized the supply of the drink through a special mineral pipeline, where filtration is simultaneously carried out and there is no contact with air. Thanks to such actions, water retains volatile substances.

Essentuki 4 mineral water is recommended for use in diseases of the digestive system, kidney disease and genitourinary system:

  • Chronic gastritis with normal, low and high acidity;
  • GERD (gastroesophageal reflux disease), with GDR (duodenogastric reflux);
  • Peptic ulcer of the stomach and duodenum, as well as rehabilitation after surgical intervention for ulcerative diseases of the stomach and duodenum;
  • Diseases of the liver and biliary tract (DLD - biliary dyskinesia, functional disorders of the gallbladder and biliary tract;
  • Chronic pancreatitis;
  • Obesity;
  • Chronic pyelonephritis;
  • Urolithiasis disease;
  • Chronic cystitis;
  • Chronic urethritis;
  • Violation of salt and lipid metabolism.

Since the composition of these mineral waters is similar, the indications for use of “Essentuki 17” are almost identical, but there are some differences.

Essentuki water for gastritis is considered a safe drink, since each batch of mineral water undergoes mandatory testing by specialists. Typically, gastroenterologists can prescribe mineral therapy up to three courses per year.

Components

The comparison table will help us choose more suitable water by eye. Remember, more is not always better. Too much concentration of some mineral water components may not be beneficial for you.

NameBorjomiEssentuki No. 4Essentuki No. 17Essentuki Healing
PurposeMedical dining roomMedical dining roomMedicalMedical dining room
Mineralization5.0-7.5 g/l7.0-10.0 g/l10.0-14.0 g/l7.0-8.0 g/l
HCO33500-5000 mg/l3400-4800 mg/l4900-6500 mg/l1600-1800 mg/l
SO4<10 mg/l<25 mg/l<25 mg/l1300-1600 mg/l
Cl250-500 mg/l1300-1900 mg/l1700-2800 mg/lLess than 80
Ca2+20-150 mg/l20-150 mg/l50-200 mg/lNo more than 20 mg/l
Mg2+20-150 mg/lLess than 100 mg/lLess than 150 mg/lNo more than 10 mg/l
Na+1000-2000 mg/l1500-2500 mg/l2200-3800 mg/dm3120-250 mg/l

Essentuki No. 4 and No. 17 also contain from 30 to 90 mg/dm3 H3BO3; no such element was found in Borjomi. As you can see, Essentuki No. 17 is endowed with the greatest mineralization, so it must be used with extreme caution. This amount of minerals, if dosed incorrectly, can lead to negative consequences.

Only experienced resort doctors can say which is better than Borjomi or Essentuki, based on the chemical composition and medicinal properties. Only their experience can give us the right answer.

Experts' opinion

According to Professor of the Department of Therapy G.I.U.V. Ministry of Defense of the Russian Federation, gastroenterologist Vladimir Gorbakov, Borjomi springs today are no longer medicinal water. There is an opinion that the military specialist made such statements against the background of the political conflict between the Russian Federation and Georgia.

Roskontrol experts made test purchases of Essentuka and Borjomi, checking them for quality and came to the following conclusions:

  • Borjomi has a lot of fakes; according to some reports, fakes reach 40% of the drink's sales.
  • Essentuka No. 4 had an overestimated chloride content. It was obviously not bottled from the source indicated on the packaging.

As we can see, Essentuki is no different from Borjomi in this regard. For the most part, experts agree that it is impossible to raise the question of which is better. For each patient it is necessary to select separately.

Essentuki 4 for gastritis with high acidity


This product helps reduce excessive secretory function of the stomach. Therefore, doctors advise drinking the liquid warm. Also, this technique will help relax the intestinal muscles, which causes stool retention, and this indicates relief from diarrhea. For gastritis, you need to drink water three times a day before meals, you need to drink quickly, and take large sips.

It is important to note that there is no analogue in the world that has the same taste and healing properties. The liquid contains sulfates, calcium, bicarbonates, chlorides, sodium, magnesium. The main feature of water is its calorie content - 0 Kcal.

Important! Medicinal water should be used only after prescription by the attending physician. The liquid can be used as a drink, but this is for healthy people.

Borjomi: composition and beneficial properties

Another water is produced in the Caucasus, and how could one compare and decide which is better, Essentuki, Narzan and Borjomi. The latter comes from the Georgian city of the same name. Although it became famous not as long ago as its competitors, today it is known far beyond the borders of Georgia. Today, by the way, one of the Georgian divisions of the Russian company is engaged in its production, you can buy it both in pharmacies and in stores, but you should be wary of counterfeits.

It’s difficult to say which is tastier, especially considering that each of them is good in its own way, and each, accordingly, has its own contraindications. Borjomi is no exception - a sodium bicarbonate mineral water, which should not be abused. Its composition has not changed for approximately 200 years, and all this time it has been studied in the laboratory.

How to take Essentuki 4 for gastritis

This product helps reduce excessive secretory function of the stomach. Therefore, doctors advise drinking the liquid warm. Also, this technique will help relax the intestinal muscles, which causes stool retention, and this indicates relief from diarrhea.

For gastritis, you need to drink water three times a day before meals, you need to drink quickly, and take large sips. It is important to note that there is no analogue in the world that has the same taste and healing properties. The liquid contains sulfates, calcium, bicarbonates, chlorides, sodium, magnesium. The main feature of water is its calorie content - 0 Kcal.

Important! Medicinal water should be used only after prescription by the attending physician. The liquid can be used as a drink, but this is for healthy people.

What mineral waters are recommended for colitis?

Mineral water for intestinal colitis:

  • "Arzni"
  • "Arshan"
  • "White Hill"
  • "Berezovskaya",
  • "Borjomi"
  • "Golden eagle",
  • "Jermuk"
  • "Dilijan"
  • "Dragovskaya",
  • "Gogolevskaya",
  • "Essentuki No. 4",
  • "Kemeri"
  • "Crimea",
  • "Kuyalnik"
  • "Luzhanskaya",
  • "Mashuk No. 19"
  • "Mirgorodskaya",
  • "Ploskovskaya",
  • "Rychalsu"
  • "Sairme"
  • "Svalyava"
  • "Skuri"
  • "Slavyanovskaya",
  • “Smirnovskaya” (without gas, 40–45 °C).

Time of administration: time of administration depends on the acidity of gastric juice.

Single dose, method of administration: at the beginning of treatment - 75-100 ml and gradually increased to 150-200 ml; The method of using water depends on the acidity of gastric juice.

Daily intake 3 times: in the morning on an empty stomach, before lunch and dinner.

How to drink Essentuki 4 correctly for gastritis

It is considered table water with medicinal properties. “Essentuki” thins the mucus formed on the gastrointestinal tract, normalizes motor/secretory function, has a mild laxative effect, and increases the overall activity of the stomach. A course of taking Essentuki should be started after consultation with a doctor (one-time use is acceptable, for example, for heartburn).

The duration of the course and dosage are determined by the doctor. If you have problems with your gastrointestinal tract, never consume Essentuki without prior consultation. Before consumption, the liquid should be cooled (to improve digestion processes) or warmed (to reduce secretory function). Daily consumption should not exceed 1200 ml. General therapy can last about a month.

It is better to consult a doctor before starting to drink Essentuki 4 water!

The course of treatment is 3-4 weeks.


  • It is considered table water with medicinal properties.
    “Essentuki” thins the mucus formed on the gastrointestinal tract, normalizes motor/secretory work, has a mild laxative effect, and increases the overall activity of the stomach. Reflux esophagitis. 150-200 ml 3 times a day 1-1.5 hours before meals. Water temperature - 38-40 degrees. You need to drink water in large sips.

  • Chronic gastritis with normal gastric secretory function. 150-200 ml 3 times a day 35-40 minutes before meals. Water temperature - 28-35 degrees. You should drink water slowly, in small sips.
  • Chronic gastritis with decreased secretory function of the stomach. 100–200 ml 3 times a day 15–30 minutes before meals. Water temperature is 18–25 degrees. Drink water slowly, in small sips.
  • In case of chronic gastritis with secretory insufficiency and diarrhea,
    the single dose of water is reduced to 50 ml, and the water temperature is increased to 40–45 degrees, and only after the patient’s clinical condition improves, they proceed to the usual doses.
  • Chronic gastritis with increased secretory function of the stomach. 150-200 ml 3 times a day 1-1.5 hours before meals. Water temperature - 38-40 degrees. You need to drink water quickly, in large sips.
  • Peptic ulcer of the stomach and duodenum . 150-200 ml 3 times a day 1-1.5 hours before meals. Water temperature - 38-40 degrees. You need to drink water quickly, in large sips.
  • Irritable bowel syndrome with diarrhea. 100 ml 3 times a day 40-60 minutes before meals. Water temperature - 40-45 degrees. Drink slowly, in small sips.
  • Irritable bowel syndrome with constipation
    . 100-200 ml 3 times a day 1-1.5 hours before meals. Water temperature - 18-20 degrees. Drink quickly, in large sips.
  • Spasmodic constipation.
    100-200 ml 3 times a day 1-1.5 hours before meals. Water temperature - 40-45 degrees. Drink slowly, in small sips.

Healing properties

Both waters help with diseases of the gastrointestinal tract, liver, metabolic disorders and related ailments. Nutritionist Lyudmila Denisenko believes that it doesn’t matter what you choose to drink from Essentuki or Borjomi, buy the product strictly at the pharmacy. In stores or supermarkets, the risk of stumbling upon a fake is much higher.

Reviews from patients are also divided, some speak in favor of Borjomi, others speak about the beneficial benefits of Essentuki waters. It's probably a matter of habit. To use these waters for medicinal purposes, be sure to consult your doctor. The choice of mineral water is a very individual process.

Essentuki Water 17. Indications for use, contraindications

Essentuki mineral water is known throughout the world as a therapeutic and prophylactic remedy for many diseases. According to the degree of influence, it is distinguished by numbers. Water is widely used for many diseases, as well as for their prevention. There are also contraindications to its use that you need to be aware of.

The benefits and harms of Essentuki 17 water are due to its invaluable biochemical content. The liquid has a beneficial effect on the vital organs of the human body, when taken correctly.

Chemical composition of Essentuki water 17

The beneficial properties of Essentuki 17 mineral water are indicated by its composition, which amazes with the richness and variety of valuable components.

1 liter of Essentuki 17 mineral water contains mg of:

Anions:

  • bicarbonate HCO3–: 4900–6500
  • sulphate SO42−: less than 25
  • Cl− chloride: 1700–2800

Cations:

  • calcium Ca2+: 50–200
  • magnesium Mg2+: less than 150
  • sodium + potassium Na++K+: 2700–4000

Boric acid H3BO3 40–90.

Dissolved carbon dioxide (in extracted mineral water) 500–2350.

The mineral spring emerges from the depths of the earth in a hot state, emitting a specific hydrogen sulfide smell.

Additional Information! The mineralization rate of Essentuki 17 alkaline water varies, ranging from 11-13 g per liter. Essentuki 17 exhibits the most beneficial properties when consumed from the source. But even after bottling, its value becomes slightly less. Harm is only possible if taken uncontrolled.

Benefits of water

The benefits of Essentuki 17 mineral water, without harm to health, are possible with strict adherence to the intake plan previously specified by the doctor. The drink is prescribed not only for prevention, but also to eliminate serious pathologies.

This is due to the healing properties of Essentuki 17:

  • improves digestion;
  • normalizes water-salt balance;
  • promotes the discharge of excess bile;
  • eliminates mucous secretions that accumulate in the respiratory organs and stomach during inflammation;
  • accelerates metabolic functions;
  • strengthens the immune system;
  • removes harmful toxins and waste;
  • restores the nervous system;
  • has a beneficial effect on kidney and liver function.

The mucolytic properties of Essentuki 17 help with cough, stimulating the rapid release of sputum. Healthy Essentuki 17 water is often prescribed for weight loss as an effective fat-burning agent.

Indications for use of Essentuki water 17

Due to the wide range of beneficial properties of Essentuki 17 mineral water, with minimal harm, it is widely used for the following diseases:

  • decreased activity of the gastrointestinal tract;
  • gastritis with low and high acidity;
  • hepatitis and other liver pathologies;
  • obesity;
  • pancreatitis;
  • cholecystitis;
  • impaired functionality of the bile ducts;
  • diabetes;
  • alcohol and other intoxication;
  • cough;
  • hormonal imbalances;
  • chronic problems with bowel movements;
  • diathesis.

The benefits of Essentuki 17 mineral water for duodenal and gastric ulcers have been noted. Essentuki 17 is a medicinal water with clearly indicated beneficial properties, but subject to dosed course intake.

It is unacceptable to drink it in unlimited quantities, as this will cause significant harm to the body.

Externally, the benefits of such a liquid are manifested in the case of: washing the skin (dermatological problems), inhalations, rinsing the mouth and rinsing the sinuses (sinusitis, sinusitis, colds).

How to drink Essentuki 17 correctly for medicinal purposes

Based on the possible harm and benefits of Essentuki 17 water for the body, independent treatment is unacceptable. Before balneotherapy, be sure to visit a doctor, who, based on the diagnosis, prescribes a course of treatment with healthy mineral water and indicates the likely harm if the prescriptions are not followed.

Important! With benefit and without harm to vital systems, Essentuki 17 mineral water can be drunk at one time, within the range of 35-260 ml. To minimize negative effects, start with a small amount and gradually increase.

Whether it is hot, warm or cool depends on the purpose. Temperature does not in any way impair its beneficial properties, but does not reduce the harm.

The harm and benefits of Essentuki 17 mineral water are affected not only by the method of consumption, but also by the volume of sips - they should be the same (large or small). First, open the water and wait for the gases to come out. It is advisable to drink the healing liquid in the morning, before breakfast.

For gastritis with decreased secretion

Mineral water is beneficial for gastritis of any origin. In case of reduced acidity, consume warm, 200 ml before each meal.

With a decrease in intestinal motor function

When intestinal motility is inhibited, taking mineral water is indicated due to its mild fixing properties in a warm state. Follow a six-week course. Drink the healthy drink slightly heated, half a two-hundred-gram glass.

For constipation and intestinal cramps

The beneficial properties of Essentuki are beneficial for antispasmodic manifestations in the stomach and intestines, which causes chronic constipation. Drink 120–200 ml of cool mineral water an hour before meals.

With stagnation of bile

No less common is therapy with healing mineral liquid for congestion of bile, at the stage of remission. It is based on a blind method, without inserting a probe device inside. The procedure is carried out on an empty stomach.

Lying on the right side and with a heating pad under the ribs (on the right side), they give you a glass of slightly heated mineral water to drink. You need to lie in this position for about 2 hours. The balneo session is carried out once or repeated several days in a row (no more than 14), focusing on the patient’s well-being.

Important! It is unacceptable to carry out tubage in case of gallstone liver pathologies, cardiac ischemia, hypertension and inflammation of the gastrointestinal tract.

For disease prevention

For health purposes, the beneficial properties of Essentuki 17 mineral water are no less pronounced. Consume throughout the month, chilled and 40 minutes before eating. Single dose – 160–250 ml. The first portion is in the morning, immediately after waking up.

City residents in environmentally unfavorable areas will benefit from such prevention once every six months.

Inhalations with mineral water Essentuki 17

Inhalations with Essentuki 17 are indicated for children and adults with colds and other pulmonary diseases, when it is necessary to relieve the inflammatory process in the nasopharynx. Such sessions help relieve acute symptoms such as persistent cough and runny nose.

Ferry

For inhalations, special devices are provided to facilitate the procedure. But in the absence of an inhaler, the benefits of inhaling mineral steam will be no less. To do this, pour a little Essentuki 17 mineral water into a heat-resistant container, place it on the stove and heat it to 70 C. Bend over, cover the top with a towel and inhale. Three minutes is enough for children, ten minutes for adults.

Using a nebulizer

How to use a nebulizer (inhaler): 1. Open mineral water in advance to reduce carbonation.2. Measure out 5–6 ml and pour into the device.3. Turn on and wait until steam formation begins.4. Breathe in the same way as over steam, adhering to a similar time interval.

This is the best way for adults and children to get rid of cough and runny nose.

Ultrasound

Ultrasonic inhalations with the Essentuki mineral drink are possible only in a hospital setting, under the supervision of a specialist. The essence of the procedure is that mineral particles penetrate into the lungs due to ultrasound. Essentuki 17 children

Therapy with Essentuki mineral water is prescribed to 17 children and adolescents exclusively by a specialist, in specific dosages, to avoid harm. The beneficial properties of Essentuki help stabilize the water-electrolyte balance that occurs due to hypothermia, overheating or dehydration. The benefits of water are also observed in cases of impaired gastrointestinal motility, constipation and dyskinesia.

Important! At the slightest suspicious manifestation, stop drinking water immediately. Otherwise, the beneficial properties of mineral water can turn into harm.

Harm of Essentuki 17 water and contraindications for use

Despite the wide range of beneficial properties of Essentuki 17, harm is possible with a thoughtless approach to such therapy and prevention. Do not ignore the existing contraindications:

  • exacerbation of any disease;
  • early age in children;
  • salt accumulations in joints;
  • hypertensive crisis;
  • cardiac dysfunctions.

Mineral water Essentuki 17 causes harm in the form of increased swelling when the kidneys are unstable.

How to distinguish Essentuki 17 from a fake

Unscrupulous suppliers often pass off counterfeit Essentuki 17 mineral water as original.

To avoid this, you should know the main signs of choosing natural products:

  • mineral water packaged in light-proof green bottles made of glass or plastic;
  • firmly glued label;
  • presence of GOST stamp;
  • the expiration date is embossed, not printed;
  • The description must contain accurate information: well number, location of the mineral spring, chemical composition.

You can definitely purchase healthy Essentuki mineral water, with the full range of medicinal properties, at the pharmacy. To confirm quality, it is recommended to ask the seller for a certificate for the product. It is reassuring that fake mineral water does not cause harm, but it also has zero benefit.

Additional Information! Natural Essentuki are not cheap due to their wide range of medicinal properties. Its price is significantly higher than similar table-type mineral analogues.

Questions and answers

Due to the popularity of the brand and the variety of such mineral waters, which differ in properties and purpose, potential consumers have a lot of questions. The most frequently asked questions are worth considering and answering.

Acidic water

Acidic water, unlike alkaline water, is especially popular in the domestic sphere. Since water with a low pH level is an acidic solution, it has a strong bactericidal effect. For this reason, such water is often used to disinfect linen in medical institutions.

Also, acidic water allows you to quickly recover from various ailments. It is often used to wash wounds for disinfection, rinse the throat, mouth and wash.

Dead water is one of the main components in alternative medicine . Thanks to it, experienced healers treat high blood pressure, reduce joint pain and eliminate cold symptoms.

Acidic water, unlike alkaline water, retains its properties for a long time. Dead water can be stored in glass containers for up to two weeks.

List of acid mineral water names:

  • Sulfate Narzan with a pH value of 6.3;
  • Essentuki No. 17 with a pH value of 6.6 wells No. 46;
  • Essentuki No. 4 with a pH value of 6.9, which can easily be classified as mineral water of neutral acidity.

This water has a low acidity level and is quite suitable for consumption, but healthy people should not abuse dead water, since it significantly increases acidity and can cause digestive disorders.

The most famous source of acidic water is “Kisly”, located in the Rostov region . Water from there can be consumed only on the recommendation of a doctor.

Mineral water differs from other drinks in that it is drunk not only to quench thirst, but also as a remedy. Alkaline mineral water occupies a special place in this series. It is useful to use as an auxiliary remedy for healing from many diseases. The list of the best alkaline mineral waters will tell you how to choose the right one and which type of water to prefer.

What mineral waters are recommended for colitis?

Mineral water for intestinal colitis:

  • "Arzni"
  • "Arshan"
  • "White Hill"
  • "Berezovskaya",
  • "Borjomi"
  • "Golden eagle",
  • "Jermuk"
  • "Dilijan"
  • "Dragovskaya",
  • "Gogolevskaya",
  • "Essentuki No. 4",
  • "Kemeri"
  • "Crimea",
  • "Kuyalnik"
  • "Luzhanskaya",
  • "Mashuk No. 19"
  • "Mirgorodskaya",
  • "Ploskovskaya",
  • "Rychalsu"
  • "Sairme"
  • "Svalyava"
  • "Skuri"
  • "Slavyanovskaya",
  • “Smirnovskaya” (without gas, 40–45 °C).

Time of administration: time of administration depends on the acidity of gastric juice.

Single dose, method of administration: at the beginning of treatment - 75-100 ml and gradually increased to 150-200 ml; The method of using water depends on the acidity of gastric juice.

Daily intake 3 times: in the morning on an empty stomach, before lunch and dinner.

Alkaline water

Alkaline water is significantly different from acidic mineral water, the list of names of which can be obtained from your doctor. Alkaline mineral water acts on the body as a biostimulant, restoring the immune system. It also activates cell regeneration, restores metabolism, and allows you to recover from stomach diseases.

Alkaline water lives up to its popular name everywhere. It is useful not only for the human body, but also has a wonderful effect on plants. Alkaline water is often used on farms, thereby significantly increasing crop yields.

Rating
( 2 ratings, average 4.5 out of 5 )
Did you like the article? Share with friends: